[ Previous Section | Next Section | Chapter Index | Main Index ]

Using Parameters
Formal and Actual Parameters
Subroutine Examples
Throwing Exceptions
Global and Local Variables

Section 4.3


If a subroutine is a black box, then a parameter provides a mechanism for passing information from the outside world into the box. Parameters are part of the interface of a subroutine. They allow you to customize the behavior of a subroutine to adapt it to a particular situation.

As an analogy, consider a thermostat -- a black box whose task it is to keep your house at a certain temperature. The thermostat has a parameter, namely the dial that is used to set the desired temperature. The thermostat always performs the same task: maintaining a constant temperature. However, the exact task that it performs -- that is, which temperature it maintains -- is customized by the setting on its dial.

4.3.1  Using Parameters

As an example, let's go back to the "3N+1" problem that was discussed in Subsection 3.2.2. (Recall that a 3N+1 sequence is computed according to the rule, "if N is odd, multiply by 3 and add 1; if N is even, divide by 2; continue until N is equal to 1." For example, starting from N=3 we get the sequence: 3, 10, 5, 16, 8, 4, 2, 1.) Suppose that we want to write a subroutine to print out such sequences. The subroutine will always perform the same task: Print out a 3N+1 sequence. But the exact sequence it prints out depends on the starting value of N. So, the starting value of N would be a parameter to the subroutine. The subroutine could be written like this:

 * This subroutine prints a 3N+1 sequence to standard output, using
 * startingValue as the initial value of N.  It also prints the number 
 * of terms in the sequence. The value of the parameter, startingValue, 
 * must  be a positive integer.

static void print3NSequence(int startingValue) {
   int N;      // One of the terms in the sequence.
   int count;  // The number of terms.
   N = startingValue;  // The first term is whatever value
                       //    is passed to the subroutine as 
                       //    a parameter.
   count = 1; // We have one term, the starting value, so far.
   System.out.println("The 3N+1 sequence starting from " + N);
   System.out.println(N);  // print initial term of sequence
   while (N > 1) {
       if (N % 2 == 1)     // is N odd?
          N = 3 * N + 1;
          N = N / 2;
       count++;   // count this term
       System.out.println(N);  // print this term
   System.out.println("There were " + count + " terms in the sequence.");

}  // end print3NSequence

The parameter list of this subroutine, "(int startingValue)", specifies that the subroutine has one parameter, of type int. Within the body of the subroutine, the parameter name can be used in the same way as a variable name. However, the parameter gets its initial value from outside the subroutine. When the subroutine is called, a value must be provided for this parameter in the subroutine call statement. This value will be assigned to the parameter, startingValue, before the body of the subroutine is executed. For example, the subroutine could be called using the subroutine call statement "print3NSequence(17);". When the computer executes this statement, the computer assigns the value 17 to startingValue and then executes the statements in the subroutine. This prints the 3N+1 sequence starting from 17. If K is a variable of type int, then when the computer executes the subroutine call statement "print3NSequence(K);", it will take the value of the variable K, assign that value to startingValue, and execute the body of the subroutine.

The class that contains print3NSequence can contain a main() routine (or other subroutines) that call print3NSequence. For example, here is a main() program that prints out 3N+1 sequences for various starting values specified by the user:

public static void main(String[] args) {
   TextIO.putln("This program will print out 3N+1 sequences");
   TextIO.putln("for starting values that you specify.");
   int K;  // Input from user; loop ends when K < 0.
   do {
      TextIO.putln("Enter a starting value.");
      TextIO.put("To end the program, enter 0: ");
      K = TextIO.getInt();  // Get starting value from user.
      if (K > 0)   // Print sequence, but only if K is > 0.
   } while (K > 0);   // Continue only if K > 0.
} // end main

Remember that before you can use this program, the definitions of main and of print3NSequence must both be wrapped inside a class definition.

4.3.2  Formal and Actual Parameters

Note that the term "parameter" is used to refer to two different, but related, concepts. There are parameters that are used in the definitions of subroutines, such as startingValue in the above example. And there are parameters that are used in subroutine call statements, such as the K in the statement "print3NSequence(K);". Parameters in a subroutine definition are called formal parameters or dummy parameters. The parameters that are passed to a subroutine when it is called are called actual parameters or arguments. When a subroutine is called, the actual parameters in the subroutine call statement are evaluated and the values are assigned to the formal parameters in the subroutine's definition. Then the body of the subroutine is executed.

A formal parameter must be a name, that is, a simple identifier. A formal parameter is very much like a variable, and -- like a variable -- it has a specified type such as int, boolean, or String. An actual parameter is a value, and so it can be specified by any expression, provided that the expression computes a value of the correct type. The type of the actual parameter must be one that could legally be assigned to the formal parameter with an assignment statement. For example, if the formal parameter is of type double, then it would be legal to pass an int as the actual parameter since ints can legally be assigned to doubles. When you call a subroutine, you must provide one actual parameter for each formal parameter in the subroutine's definition. Consider, for example, a subroutine

static void doTask(int N, double x, boolean test) {
    // statements to perform the task go here

This subroutine might be called with the statement

doTask(17, Math.sqrt(z+1), z >= 10);

When the computer executes this statement, it has essentially the same effect as the block of statements:

  int N;       // Allocate memory locations for the formal parameters.
  double x;
  boolean test;
  N = 17;              // Assign 17 to the first formal parameter, N.
  x = Math.sqrt(z+1);  // Compute Math.sqrt(z+1), and assign it to
                       //    the second formal parameter, x.
  test = (z >= 10);    // Evaluate "z >= 10" and assign the resulting
                       //     true/false value to the third formal 
                       //     parameter, test.
   // statements to perform the task go here

(There are a few technical differences between this and "doTask(17,Math.sqrt(z+1),z>=10);" -- besides the amount of typing -- because of questions about scope of variables and what happens when several variables or parameters have the same name.)

Beginning programming students often find parameters to be surprisingly confusing. Calling a subroutine that already exists is not a problem -- the idea of providing information to the subroutine in a parameter is clear enough. Writing the subroutine definition is another matter. A common mistake is to assign values to the formal parameters at the beginning of the subroutine, or to ask the user to input their values. This represents a fundamental misunderstanding. When the statements in the subroutine are executed, the formal parameters will already have values. The values come from the subroutine call statement. Remember that a subroutine is not independent. It is called by some other routine, and it is the calling routine's responsibility to provide appropriate values for the parameters.

4.3.3  Overloading

In order to call a subroutine legally, you need to know its name, you need to know how many formal parameters it has, and you need to know the type of each parameter. This information is called the subroutine's signature. The signature of the subroutine doTask, used as an example above, can be expressed as as: doTask(int,double,boolean). Note that the signature does not include the names of the parameters; in fact, if you just want to use the subroutine, you don't even need to know what the formal parameter names are, so the names are not part of the interface.

Java is somewhat unusual in that it allows two different subroutines in the same class to have the same name, provided that their signatures are different. (The language C++ on which Java is based also has this feature.) When this happens, we say that the name of the subroutine is overloaded because it has several different meanings. The computer doesn't get the subroutines mixed up. It can tell which one you want to call by the number and types of the actual parameters that you provide in the subroutine call statement. You have already seen overloading used in the TextIO class. This class includes many different methods named putln, for example. These methods all have different signatures, such as:

putln(int)                   putln(double)
putln(String)                putln(char)
putln(boolean)               putln()

The computer knows which of these subroutines you want to use based on the type of the actual parameter that you provide. TextIO.putln(17) calls the subroutine with signature putln(int), while TextIO.putln("Hello") calls the subroutine with signature putln(String). Of course all these different subroutines are semantically related, which is why it is acceptable programming style to use the same name for them all. But as far as the computer is concerned, printing out an int is very different from printing out a String, which is different from printing out a boolean, and so forth -- so that each of these operations requires a different method.

Note, by the way, that the signature does not include the subroutine's return type. It is illegal to have two subroutines in the same class that have the same signature but that have different return types. For example, it would be a syntax error for a class to contain two methods defined as:

int    getln() { ... }
double getln() { ... }

So it should be no surprise that in the TextIO class, the methods for reading different types are not all named getln(). In a given class, there can only be one routine that has the name getln and has no parameters. So, the input routines in TextIO are distinguished by having different names, such as getlnInt() and getlnDouble().

Java 5.0 introduced another complication: It is possible to have a single subroutine that takes a variable number of actual parameters. You have already used subroutines that do this -- the formatted output routines System.out.printf and TextIO.putf. When you call these subroutines, the number of parameters in the subroutine call can be arbitrarily large, so it would be impossible to have different subroutines to handle each case. Unfortunately, writing the definition of such a subroutine requires some knowledge of arrays, which will not be covered until Chapter 7. When we get to that chapter, you'll learn how to write subroutines with a variable number of parameters. For now, we will ignore this complication.

4.3.4  Subroutine Examples

Let's do a few examples of writing small subroutines to perform assigned tasks. Of course, this is only one side of programming with subroutines. The task performed by a subroutine is always a subtask in a larger program. The art of designing those programs -- of deciding how to break them up into subtasks -- is the other side of programming with subroutines. We'll return to the question of program design in Section 4.6.

As a first example, let's write a subroutine to compute and print out all the divisors of a given positive integer. The integer will be a parameter to the subroutine. Remember that the syntax of any subroutine is:

modifiers  return-type  subroutine-name  ( parameter-list ) {

Writing a subroutine always means filling out this format. In this case, the statement of the problem tells us that there is one parameter, of type int, and it tells us what the statements in the body of the subroutine should do. Since we are only working with static subroutines for now, we'll need to use static as a modifier. We could add an access modifier (public or private), but in the absence of any instructions, I'll leave it out. Since we are not told to return a value, the return type is void. Since no names are specified, we'll have to make up names for the formal parameter and for the subroutine itself. I'll use N for the parameter and printDivisors for the subroutine name. The subroutine will look like

static void printDivisors( int N ) {

and all we have left to do is to write the statements that make up the body of the routine. This is not difficult. Just remember that you have to write the body assuming that N already has a value! The algorithm is: "For each possible divisor D in the range from 1 to N, if D evenly divides N, then print D." Written in Java, this becomes:

 * Print all the divisors of N.
 * We assume that N is a positive integer.

static void printDivisors( int N ) {
    int D;   // One of the possible divisors of N.
    System.out.println("The divisors of " + N + " are:");
    for ( D = 1; D <= N; D++ ) {
       if ( N % D == 0 )

I've added a comment before the subroutine definition indicating the contract of the subroutine -- that is, what it does and what assumptions it makes. The contract includes the assumption that N is a positive integer. It is up to the caller of the subroutine to make sure that this assumption is satisfied.

As a second short example, consider the problem: Write a subroutine named printRow. It should have a parameter ch of type char and a parameter N of type int. The subroutine should print out a line of text containing N copies of the character ch.

Here, we are told the name of the subroutine and the names of the two parameters, so we don't have much choice about the first line of the subroutine definition. The task in this case is pretty simple, so the body of the subroutine is easy to write. The complete subroutine is given by

 * Write one line of output containing N copies of the
 * character ch.  If N <= 0, an empty line is output.

static void printRow( char ch, int N ) {
    int i;  // Loop-control variable for counting off the copies.
    for ( i = 1; i <= N; i++ ) {
        System.out.print( ch );

Note that in this case, the contract makes no assumption about N, but it makes it clear what will happen in all cases, including the unexpected case that N < 0.

Finally, let's do an example that shows how one subroutine can build on another. Let's write a subroutine that takes a String as a parameter. For each character in the string, it will print a line of output containing 25 copies of that character. It should use the printRow() subroutine to produce the output.

Again, we get to choose a name for the subroutine and a name for the parameter. I'll call the subroutine printRowsFromString and the parameter str. The algorithm is pretty clear: For each position i in the string str, call printRow(str.charAt(i),25) to print one line of the output. So, we get:

 * For each character in str, write a line of output
 * containing 25 copies of that character.

static void printRowsFromString( String str ) {
    int i;  // Loop-control variable for counting off the chars.
    for ( i = 0; i < str.length(); i++ ) {
        printRow( str.charAt(i), 25 );

We could use printRowsFromString in a main() routine such as

public static void main(String[] args) {
    String inputLine;  // Line of text input by user.
    TextIO.put("Enter a line of text: ");
    inputLine = TextIO.getln();
    printRowsFromString( inputLine );

Of course, the three routines, main(), printRowsFromString(), and printRow(), would have to be collected together inside the same class. The program is rather useless, but it does demonstrate the use of subroutines. You'll find the program in the file RowsOfChars.java, if you want to take a look. Here's an applet that simulates the program:

4.3.5  Throwing Exceptions

I have been talking about the "contract" of a subroutine. The contract says what the subroutine will do, provided that the caller of the subroutine provides acceptable values for subroutine's parameters. The question arises, though, what should the subroutine do when the caller violates the contract by providing bad parameter values?

We've already seen that some subroutines respond to bad parameter values by throwing exceptions. (See Section 3.7.) For example, the contract of the built-in subroutine Double.parseDouble says that the parameter should be a string representation of a number of type double; if this is true, then the subroutine will convert the string into the equivalent numeric value. If the caller violates the contract by passing an invalid string as the actual parameter, the subroutine responds by throwing an exception of type NumberFormatException.

Many subroutines throw IllegalArgumentExceptions in response to bad parameter values. You might want to take this response in your own subroutines. This can be done with a throw statement. An exception is an object, and in order to throw an exception, you must create an exception object. You won't officially learn how to do this until Chapter 5, but for now, you can use the following syntax for a throw statement that throws an IllegalArgumentException:

throw  new  IllegalArgumentException( error-message );

where error-message is a string that describes the error that has been detected. (The word "new" in this statement is what creates the object.) To use this statement in a subroutine, you would check whether the values of the parameters are legal. If not, you would throw the exception. For example, consider the print3NSequence subroutine from the beginning of this section. The parameter of print3NSequence is supposed to be a positive integer. We can modify the subroutine definition to make it throw an exception when this condition is violated:

static void print3NSequence(int startingValue) {
   if (startingValue <= 0)  // The contract is violated!
      throw new IllegalArgumentException( "Starting value must be positive." );
   .  // (The rest of the subroutine is the same as before.)

If the start value is bad, the computer executes the throw statement. This will immediately terminate the subroutine, without executing the rest of the body of the subroutine. Furthermore, the program as a whole will crash unless the exception is "caught" and handled elsewhere in the program by a try..catch statement, as discussed in Section 3.7.

4.3.6  Global and Local Variables

I'll finish this section on parameters by noting that we now have three different sorts of variables that can be used inside a subroutine: local variables declared in the subroutine, formal parameter names, and static member variables that are declared outside the subroutine but inside the same class as the subroutine.

Local variables have no connection to the outside world; they are purely part of the internal working of the subroutine. Parameters are used to "drop" values into the subroutine when it is called, but once the subroutine starts executing, parameters act much like local variables. Changes made inside a subroutine to a formal parameter have no effect on the rest of the program (at least if the type of the parameter is one of the primitive types -- things are more complicated in the case of objects, as we'll see later).

Things are different when a subroutine uses a variable that is defined outside the subroutine. That variable exists independently of the subroutine, and it is accessible to other parts of the program, as well as to the subroutine. Such a variable is said to be global to the subroutine, as opposed to the local variables defined inside the subroutine. The scope of a global variable includes the entire class in which it is defined. Changes made to a global variable can have effects that extend outside the subroutine where the changes are made. You've seen how this works in the last example in the previous section, where the value of the global variable, gamesWon, is computed inside a subroutine and is used in the main() routine.

It's not always bad to use global variables in subroutines, but you should realize that the global variable then has to be considered part of the subroutine's interface. The subroutine uses the global variable to communicate with the rest of the program. This is a kind of sneaky, back-door communication that is less visible than communication done through parameters, and it risks violating the rule that the interface of a black box should be straightforward and easy to understand. So before you use a global variable in a subroutine, you should consider whether it's really necessary.

I don't advise you to take an absolute stand against using global variables inside subroutines. There is at least one good reason to do it: If you think of the class as a whole as being a kind of black box, it can be very reasonable to let the subroutines inside that box be a little sneaky about communicating with each other, if that will make the class as a whole look simpler from the outside.

[ Previous Section | Next Section | Chapter Index | Main Index ]